Buy them all - You can t go wrong with any Nerf Herder album. High School and Fight For Your Right are my personal favorites
a five on the pop-punk scale - Nerf Herder is probably the catchiest pop-punk next to the Vandals. The are no Ramones, but they play the best kind of pop-punk...funny and humorous. When I say pop-punk I don t mean Good Charlotte or Simple Plan. Not like that stuff at all. Nerf Herder play up-tempo, extremely funny, slightly perverted (no cussing really though, if that matters to ya) punk that just kicks it. I can t really tell you why this album gets a 5, you gotta hear it for yourself. For fans of NOFX, the Vandals, Guttermouth, the like
Pretty good - I think this is a must have for all(the diehard) Nerf herder fans, because it s a re-released with some funny new songs and classics, so buy it now ....don t forget the video...
For the diehard fans only... - While the first few tracks on Nerf Herder s My E.P. (orginally released on Joey Cape s now dead label, My Records) still stand as some of Nerf s funniest songs, the three new songs (four counting the bonus track) suffer from the same problem that the majority of their last album, American Cheese, did: it s just not that good. None of it stacks up to any of the lyrics from How to Meet Girls or music from Nerf Herder. However, it s still worth a buy to hear the original songs remixed and remastered (they all sound excellent), and to see the very funny Sportsman Bar music video. But note that the orginal bonus track, Come Back Down has been removed.